[Confederacy]

Changing the flag colors would be best to not offend anyone, I'am right to assume the design of the flag is what appeals to you gentlemen that created this clan?

[Trafalgars, Pavel & Repair modules and crew]

or at least add slightly bigger guns than what 9lbers on the deck and the one below it

[Idea for dupe free surrender mechanic]

Maybe add the ability to say to player give xx amount of gold and we will let you go or something

[Hailing ships/Inspecting ships for contraband.]

Currently you hail a trader ship and you automatically see if they have contraband I suggest instead you receive the option of telling the trader to stop for inspection or be sent to davey jones locker.

 

The AI/Player can choose to keep sailing or not and risk being caught and sunk or submit to inspection. And from there you crew boards ship and for random chance find contraband you can initiate boarding combat and take the ship and contraband and prisoners.

[Option to turn lanterns (running lights) on at night - fog calls in fog]

It be cool but in OW i guess it would be a resource hog?

[Arranged Weekend Trafalgars anyone???]

I think it should bea mix of ts and chat

[Internal HP-Bar]

Lets keep it simple shoot bad guy till one side is gone he sinks that is all that really matters at the end of the day stop trying to making it more complex

[problem with ow graphics]

Never had that problem on my NViDIA 

[Help Identify ship!]

Surcouf is wrong though it is not the La Couronne this is the La Couronne 

 

http://www.sailboatmodel.info/la_couronne_1636/index.php?id=15

[Re-Victualisation - How long can various ships spend at see without re-provisioning?]

If this gets implemented a good cost for provisions is 50 gold per day based on the amount of crew.  One bundle of food is enough to feed 50 crew for a day.

 

 

So a constitution with say 450 crew would cost 7,500 gold to sail 15 days.

 

Bellona 9,750

 

Victory 12,750

 

 

Cost can be adjusted of course

[The feeling of speed at sea]

OW feels like speedboats.

 

Most likely will not change much.

[Taking friendly fire and 2 players the same person.]

No evidence means its hard to make a judgement on this.

[Steam Authentication error]

awe bummer

[Steam Authentication error]

Well earlier today i was able to play Naval Action fine, logged off to eat and now I can't get back in game due to steam authentication error

[More interesting way to rise in game necessary?]

What line ships will be limited by honor pvp kill?

[Nornica LoL]

a helping hand to sink

 

 

[Second rate - Pavel in game screenies]

I listened that the L/R armor it´s the same like the bellona, is true?

 

To me the armor of the Pavel seems less than the Bellona

[Second rate - Pavel in game screenies]

I wonder about her armament 

 

http://threedecks.org/index.php?display_type=show_ship&id=21416

 

what is a pood edinorog? also I think the ship should be able to support 12 or 18lbers on the 3rd deck instead of 9lbers.

[Second rate - Pavel in game screenies]

I have been debating putting carronades on the decks that have 9lbers (if you can on the 10 deck?) I wonder what the damage output would be like having 12 carronades.

[Nation Available Ships/Upgrades]

I don't think the devs wan't to limit what players can sail

[National traits (faction differences)]

While the idea is interesting,

 

Personally, I'm going to have to say " No " to the idea. Having such additions/limitations for Nations would handcuff a players ability to play how they would like for their chosen nation.

 

Ex: If a new player choose to sail under the Spanish flag, but also wants to be a Trader for that Nation. He's now a lesser Trader then any of the Nations with a +10% cargo/sale price bonus. 

 

So in short, if he wants to be an effective trader he's now forced to a nation that has Trading bonuses? 

 

However, your idea could work as a Nation sub-choice . Every nation would have the same bonuses in certain fields but broken down into " Career Paths "

 

Military Captain - +5% crew/gunnery skills (unlocks SOL's)

Trade Captain  -  +5% cargo hold/sale price (unlocks Merchant vessels)

 

So on and so fourth. This would at least allow a player to choose their Nation. And then their career path that best suits their play style.

 

 

~Cheers

 

This would be too similar to classes for which we are trying to avoid,

[Players should recognize cannon caliber by its sound.]

I feel the larger cannons on the Bellona, the 32lbers get muffled out by the 24s and 12s, Also the 24s sound a lot like the 12s to me.

[More casualties during combat]

An increase in crew loss would mean your ship will become unplayable very shortly in a battle and I'm pretty sure nobody wan'ts that.

[Dynamic Environment]

Agreed.

[Ship Heel effect too great in battle]

I remember in sea trials that the Bellona didn't heel as much as it does now, there are times where I had to reverse the rigging so i can get my broadside off in time.