I would like to know what about practise fights... I know lots of very good players on different sides from another game (POTBS)
I would not mind meeting them somewhere to have practice fights. I know a decent amount of them would improve my skill. But according to this i have to kill them and can't do those fights without the kill. It would make me a damagefarmer since i would get xp and money but no kills. What about arranged pvp fights? In POTBS there were tons of people arranging fights. And because of respect of the opponent you didn't kill him. Even in general adhoc pvp fights people choose to let enemies sail away when the fight was pretty much won.
Don't forget this is a social game also. The diplomatics, respect for your opponents, etc. In my opinion in no way this is the propper solution for damagefarming.
You take away a part of the game that does make this game very fun!. So i would love to see a responce from devs on this.