I would say
1)Battle1
2)Storm 1
3)Fleet 1
4)Victory 5
5)Deck 1
As for dislikes I only have 1
x)Victory 6 (too close to lighthouse)
For advertisement purposes I would recommend the following;
1)Wargamer.com (you may want to contact them to do an actual interview about the game as well)
2)Google adwords-pick keywords ie.-ship of the line game, naval warfare game, napoleonic game, etc. Whatever key words you think people may type into google search. You pay everytime someone clicks on your link after they search these words. You set your own budget (like maybe 50 cents a click) and you set your own budget monthly. If there are any others out there advertising the same keyword, it becomes like a bid between cost per click. I think you would be safe using a low budget and low cost per click to find people who may be interested in this type of niche game.
3)The people who have been following this game from the beginning are gonna be a high source of advertisement. I belong to a napoleonic gaming community (Lordz Modding Collective) with over 5,000 people registered on our forum. I personally am going to put links up to direct people to this game. Find out how to contact groups that played age of sail and potbs (I think many of them found you).
4)Give some kind of kudos to those mentioned above in 3). Early access would be nice
Anyways, I hope this helps and thank you for all your hard work gents!