Jump to content
Game-Labs Forum

Arvenski

Members2
  • Posts

    913
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Arvenski

  1.  

    If they had broken it down into a vote for a lineship and a ship frigate or below, I would give that second vote to Christian VII, even though I know what we need is 4th rates.  Christian VII is the most beautiful of the proposed SoLs by far, and a fills an interesting niche at the top end. 

    Honestly, I hope Christian VII gets chosen as the wild card, if she doesn't win (and it doesn't look like she will, at this rate). This is what, the third vote she's come up short in? IIRC she was a serious contender in last year's poll and lost, and then it seemed to me that she and Bucentaure were both popular choices in that "Ship request-2nd Rate" thread, and she apparently lost to Bucentaure. If you ask me, it's time she got selected to be in-game. 

    • Like 1
  2. And im not disagreeing, just saying i dont think the 74 gun range is one of those slots.

    Fair enough. 

     

     

    We need a Corvette to fil in the gap between ingame Brigs and light frigates and fight against Brigs, Snow, Mercury, Niagara and Cerberus.

    A opponent of the soon-in-game USS Rattlesnake : Descubierta, the Venetian Corvette or the Ch​ristiansborg.

     

    I may have a slight preference for the Descubierta and her 2 versions : a 16-gun Exploration vessel and a 26-gun military ship.

    Christiansborg's certainly pretty. It's a pity no-one's voted for her yet. 

  3. The thing though is, the Bellona and the vrijhijd seem similar

    They really do look similar (to my eyes, at least). I'm not going to disagree with you there. That being said, I'm not really campaigning for Vrijiheid so much as against Admiraal de Ruyter. I didn't even vote for Vrijiheid at first, even though she was my proposal. I voted for Prinds Christian Frederik, but since nobody else had done so, I figured that there wasn't a point in wasting a vote on a ship that looked like it wasn't going to be a competitor. 

     

    And I'm not even trying to argue with people; I'm just trying to point out that to me, it seems like the 80-gun ship category has gotten enough attention for a while, and that maybe we could use other ships more. 

  4. The same thing can be said about the vrijjheid though, she is another 74 gunner, just like we allready have the bellona and the third rate.

    No, I don't think it can. Bellona's been around for ages, and the third rate's just generic, and possibly even just a temporary placeholder. So, if we ignore the third rate, Bellona's the only 74 we've got, which, IMO, means that we could do with more. As for 80-gunners, however, Pavel was introduced fairly recently, Bucentaure's still in development, and you want yet another one? If you ask me, Admiraal de Ruyter's right up there with that Mars brig (that nobody's voted for, by the way) in the "ships that we don't need right now" category. 

  5. Wow, my Vrijiheid made it in! But the choice between her, Prinds Christian Frederik, and Christian VII... 

     

    Also, why are people voting for Admiraal de Ruyter? I mean, she's not a bad ship, but just remember that we've got one 80-gunner in game (Pavel) and another one in development (Bucentaure). It seems kinda unnecessary, in my humble opinion, for a third one to be added at this time. 

    • Like 1
  6. some of these ships are playermodeled but not yet aproved or moved to the game.

    some are playervoted ones some dev wildcards and some ships we are not allowed to tell you anything about them yet

    You mean these ships, from the wiki?

     

     

    Not confirmed however likely to come in:

    Swan class

    Diana

    Agamemnon

    Panteleimon-Victoria

    Kepler

  7. Darn, it didn't occur to me to think of datamining as a source of some of this kind of info. Okay, cool. :)

     

    As for Kepler, that was the one name that was familiar to me. It was listed here (whether as a tease or by mistake, I don't know): http://forum.game-labs.net/index.php?/topic/7706-naval-action-ship-sizes-and-dimensions/

    Note the "Project von Kepler" entry. I dunno, maybe someone can take a guess at what she is based on her dimensions. I'm not an expert on this sort of thing, but she looks to be about as big as a Bellona, though not as tall from keel to top deck. Could she be a razee?

×
×
  • Create New...