Col_Kelly
-
Posts
864 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Downloads
Events
Posts posted by Col_Kelly
-
-
It was an AI brigade so I can't say for sure. I know for a fact that large Union brigades at Bull Run really suck in efficiency but that's it. I indeed use 2* and 3* speed a lot.
An increase in base damage level sounds about right, I'm sure you can do that without hurting the mod's objectives in terms of gameplay.
Kudos as well on the cap increase for skirms and cav. Having large units of those opens a lot more options for combined arms warfare while the vanilla game could someone force you into a infantry spam.
-
The mod is great in many aspects and I really appreciate the work you guys did, especially on the various carreer and officer buffs. One thing though is the slow damage of early rifles. I've seen AI Union brigades 4000 strong being barely able to kill 12 opponents at (actual) point blank range (First Bull Run, Hard difficulty). Even with low efficiency this sounds a bit excessive and battles are prolonged unnecessarily.
I really enjoy the idea of slower combat for many reasons (historical accuracy, bigger importance of smart planning etc...) but in my opinion it is too... slow at the moment. Adding a few points to close range damage to early rifles would really add some spice and also actually help the AI as it is quite easy right now to hold him off with two tiny brigades.
Anyway great work, I hope you keep improving on it.
-
2
-
-
Regarding your questions with prisoners earlier Lava.
As a player you'll always make better use of theses troops than the AI, therefore a 1/1 trade is actually advantageous for you imo. But then as far as I remember the recruit pool isnt such an issue for the Union so you don't have to try hard for manpower as much as you would with CSA. Tough question overall.
-
72.000
-
Thanks, regarding ur question it depends on the size of your enemy really.
-
New video is here. Enjoy lads.
-
1
-
-
Very nicely done, looks much better than what I've got. Would be interesting to know if in such context Antietam is worth fighting campaign wise
-
1
-
-
They wont deploy at all. Better to shift those four brigades in another corps
-
1
-
-
Apart from a few exceptions I never spend more than 10k $ on the replenishment of one brigade. It's not the end of the wolrd to lose a star 'except for arty arguably), the unit's global stats still improve overtime. Don't be afraid to use rookies.
-
2
-
-
Early on I prefer to place my 2 star brigades on the flanks whenever I can : less damage taken, more damage given. That's why it's important to always bring at least two rookie brigades in every fight so they can act as tanks for your entire army. It's also helpful to constantly estimate the range of enemy brigade and place yourself accordingly to avoid their fire.
-
1
-
-
New vid's out. Enjoy
-
3
-
-
Stats are indeed not capped at 100, it's only the max displayed value as Bramborough said
-
2
-
-
It was fragile but I couldn't do much else but holding. Despite the fact that I destroyed almost 80% of the 1st wave by encircling it the AI still had the number and veterancy to keep coming at me while pinning me down in other parts of the line. This is why I hate this battle, it forces you into static defense yet you don't have any fortifications and the numbers are really disfavorable.
-
Not just yet but I've got a surprise for y'all.
-
1
-
-
1v1 odds at Fredericksburg ? That clearly means you've destroyed the Union before that. It's definitly time you try Legendary sir
-
1
-
-
On 29/12/2017 at 6:28 AM, Mr. Mercanto said:
Its definitely the best history of Reconstruction on film, granted there are few other films that touch this, but those that do, do quite poorly.
If you're looking for a 100% historically accurate Civil War film, then I wish you the best of luck, and I suspect you'll find it with the Tooth Fairy 
.
As for its watch ability. The film has terrible pacing, but meh, I'm viewing it as a historian, not a popcorn eating spectator. You want watchable, watch National Treasure lol.Come on Mercanto we all know your favorite movies are Gods and Generals along with Field of Lost Shoes
-
1
-
-
Yeah weapons is definitly the best choice throughout the entire campaign. Before Washington I'd advise to get cash or manpower depending on what u need the most
-
1
-
-
Really sorry guys, exams, then Xmas and most of the free time goes to my team on Rising Storm 2. I should be able to start uploading again in early january
-
1
-
-
Pt 27 is here, sorry again for the slow upload rate
-
1 minute ago, Grimthaur said:
For me it worked well, mb i was lucky.
Were you playing on Legendary ? Maybe I'll try that for learning's sake.
It was definitly a sloppy tactical choice but a deliberate one : strategically speaking it felt like the best option to me : high losses for me but twice more losses for them, and my prime goal was to deplete their army stat.
-
It would work on normal or hard but in legendary every AI unit outclasses you by a wide margin. Going for a hammer an anvil move means a thin stretched line and the unability to make a quick, decisive push anywhere. Then I'd barely have the time to capture the VP and to kill a large amount of Yankees. Yet because of the Overland's campaign difficulty I really need to reduce the Union's numbers, that's why I went for a blunt approach.
-
A genuine slaughter, Enjoy
-
4
-
-
The second part of the Army camp has just been uploaded. Mansfield is next
-
1
-
-
It's normal that you don't get your full army. The last division of the last corps arrives next day. If you win early then it won't hit the battlefield.
This is the confederate campaign, it's made hard for a reason. Being largely outnumbered just represents the south's disadvantage in manpower. I know it can be frustrating but that kind of difficulty can be overcome by rethinking yourstrategy and your army setup.
-
1
-
If you're looking for a 100% historically accurate Civil War film, then I wish you the best of luck, and I suspect you'll find it with the Tooth Fairy 
. 
J & P Rebalance Mod by JonnyH13 and Pandakraut 05/06/2023 1.28.4
in General Discussions
Posted
A quick message from an old veteran in order to congratulate both Johny and Panda for their work. Just retried the mod yesterday and it now brings a completely different game to the table. I especially like the importance of fatigue as it forces us to be way more realistic in our tactics (No more sweeping attacks on the double quick across entire miles). Being able to merge brigades is also quite huge (way more than it seems at first) as army management becomes a lot simpler (and once again, more realistic).
A quick question : Is there still an efficiency drop for artillery batteries beyond 12 guns or has that been fixed as well ?