We are letting Pirates be Pirates hence this thread, it's you Pirates calling foul here because one group want to be exactly that ........be PIRATES!
Pirates are calling him treacherous, disloyal, ruining the game for Pirates... I mean really, when i first read this I thought it a joke. Surely he has as much right to be a Pirate as you guys?
....As for the usual reference to a Pirate nation, come on.... Libertatia was no more than a hippy community on an island. Not a nation!