I am very curious if any of you here on the forums have ever played East India Company.
Personally, I thought that the naval combat engine was a bit sub-par. However, coming from PotBS, I did like few aspects of the direct ship control.
Most notably, the ability to change your perspective in the 1st person view from the view of the helmsman/Captain to facing either port or starboard side, or facing off the bow or stern. In PotBS, you can zoom in close enough to get a sort of 1st person view, but you are stuck in that one spot, the camera will only ever rotate and zoom around that one central node (the player's avatar on the ship),
However, in EIC there is little camera freedom when in the direct control mode. You are not allowed to rotate or zoom with the camera, something I consider a drawback. While on one of the broadsides, one should at least be able to rotate a 180 from bow to stern for that side.
I would very much like to see the ability to have different 1st person vantage points from the ship while in combat. Perhaps even amongst the rigging.