Just some quick comments - they probably echo those of others. If so, consider them additional votes.
First, the kudos - hadn't played for a couple of weeks and appreciated the new port map, a rip-roaring thunderstorm and the scenic stern lights.
Suggestions:
As others have said, more people on deck, including officers and marines.
Cannon recoil
Sea Gulls, and perhaps other sea-life, without over doing it.
More variety of damage, falling yards, broken railings, severed ropes etc.
Better holes in the sails, right now the torn edges look very solid, like a hole in wood, rather than fabric.
Thanks again,