Jump to content
Game-Labs Forum

Farquharson, largest, most well armed and very fast merchant ship 3D model


Recommended Posts

Shouldn't the Cargo Space rather limited in such a heavily armed ship? I mean all these Cannons have to weight something and also take a lot of Space.

Indiamans are generally Shipf of the line with the Hull not pierced for all guns if you look at her she has enough freeboard to add another gundeck turning her into and 80gun ship like Bucantaure or Saint Paul.

and early one most Indiamans were converted into warships when needed HMS Glatton is one of theses who fought at the battle of Coppenhagen

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Indiamans are generally Shipf of the line with the Hull not pierced for all guns if you look at her she has enough freeboard to add another gundeck turning her into and 80gun ship like Bucantaure or Saint Paul.

and early one most Indiamans were converted into warships when needed HMS Glatton is one of theses who fought at the battle of Coppenhagen

indeed Mr Mirones the frames and planking of the East India Company "Regular ships" was identical in thickness and spacing to that of Royal Navy third rates

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The redeeming factor as far as speed goes for an East Indiamen is that they may be boxy, but its a surprisingly long and narrow box.

 

With no need for broad decks to carry heavy guns, the larger Indiamen such as Farquharson have a length to beam ratio of just over 4-to-1, only the longest and finest beamed frigates even approach this and most are nearer 3.75-to-1.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

add that one and it can fight this east indiaman(Swedish 60 gun ship) :D

wasaf10.jpg

60 gun Wasa Class / later Improved Gustav adolf Class by chapman.

no need to say that it will get run over by Fargu and fliped because of the large size difrence

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

60 gun Wasa Class / later Improved Gustav adolf Class by chapman.

no need to say that it will get run over by Fargu and fliped because of the large size difrence

 

 

Gustav Adolphs were smaller, but most of them carried 24s on the upper deck and 36s on the gun deck. And they were faster (10 3/4 close-hauled / 13 running free).

 

The Farquharson is the king the merchant ships, though.

Edited by Malachi
Link to comment
Share on other sites

She's a pretty ship, sleek and modern despite her size.  Great work in constructing her Ragnar!

 

My only fear is that this ship will be the one and only preferred merchant ship in the game.  With such a large hold, speed and cannons, why bother having a navy or escorts?

 

I mean, yes she was built in 1820, but just like my example about the USS Demologos, just because she's in the time period does not mean that she fits into the game.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

She's a pretty ship, sleek and modern despite her size.  Great work in constructing her Ragnar!

 

My only fear is that this ship will be the one and only preferred merchant ship in the game.  With such a large hold, speed and cannons, why bother having a navy or escorts?

 

I mean, yes she was built in 1820, but just like my example about the USS Demologos, just because she's in the time period does not mean that she fits into the game.

im not sure that such a vessel would be the only choice of merchant ship "santi isnt the only choice of warship", and besides she was huge but her guns are only 18lb  and with only 250 to 300 crew a skilled officer in a connie or similar vessel could just stay on her stern take down her sails and board.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

im not sure that such a vessel would be the only choice of merchant ship "santi isnt the only choice of warship", and besides she was huge but her guns are only 18lb  and with only 250 to 300 crew a skilled officer in a connie or similar vessel could just stay on her stern take down her sails and board.

 

True, but I am trying to compare her to other merchant ships, not warships.

 

I mean, I like the ship, but I am just trying to figure out what her role would be in comparison to a standard East Indianman.  

 

The Indianman would be smaller and slower, possibly with a bit heavier guns and better armor thickness, but because the Indianman is slower she is going to be chased down and attacked more often, which is obviously not something a merchant captain would really want.

 

The Farquharson on the other hand is larger, faster and still reasonably heavily armed.  She exceeds in all classes of what a merchant wants, speed and cargo space.  Therefore, the Farquharson would become more preferred by merchant captains than an Indianman.

 

Now, the one big thing that would balance her out in my opinion is the more loaded a ship is, the worse that ship preforms in all sailing conditions, speed, turn rate, etc. regardless in the open sea or in the battle instance (and if this feature is already in the game, then it needs to be buffed as I have not been able to notice it). Therefore, a loaded Farguharson sail significantly slower, making her more likely to fall prey by other warships.  Because she does not have the armor or the heavier weight firepower of an Indianman, she will not be nearly as effective.

  • Like 7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

she would have more armor than the standard indiaman sir! not less and yes the more cargo the slower it would go but then the same thing for other merchant ships should apply....whos to say that there wont be large (not larger) but faster armed merchant ships for us to sail... Merchant frigates like those deigned by Chapman.

 

 

 

She has the same frame and plank thickness and spacing as a British 3rd rate....Same armor as a Bellona.

 

easy answer would be to make them very very expensive to craft?????

Edited by ragnar hairy trousers
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...