Jump to content
Game-Labs Forum

Juan Navarre

Members
  • Content count

    55
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Juan Navarre last won the day on June 4

Juan Navarre had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

86 Excellent

About Juan Navarre

  • Rank
    Ordinary seaman
  1. +1 Beyond getting stuck, I understand that there is some historical precedent for ships running into underwater rocks suffering some kind of damage. It would be great to see naval strategy pull some more weight in the game. It seems to me that the strategy in the game currently is all about choosing which mods and upgrades to ruin the authenticity of your ship's performance with. Getting the weather gauge and keeping your bearings provides precious little advantage compared with having l337 sniper skilz. Having to pay attention to shallows would go a long way to bringing some more strategy into the game.
  2. Juan Navarre

    After battle loot screen

    What a gnat to strain at. After a battle in which masts are regrown like Tom Bombadill is singing to them, the ship's necromancer raises the dead with an elixir of rum, the ship's diviner casts entrails to see the enemy's numbers, the integrity of their hull, and the effectiveness of their sails... Goodness gracious, half the 'captains' wouldn't know windward from leeward without Gandalf's magic arrow to point it out to them. But by all means, the salvage operations after the wizard's duel is over are the perfect time to strive for authenticity.
  3. Juan Navarre

    Fun PVE for everyone?!

    The ships are very beautiful, and so is the environment. As soon as the amazing sailing part gets implemented, I think it will fill the same role that has created this demand for more PvE content. If you look at the OP, here is the reasoning behind the desire for PvE content: If the amazing sailing you advertised were implemented, it would fill all these needs. There would be something to do when the game has low numbers. It would cater to the historians and modelers who want to sail around in historically accurate decks of history, with authentic performance in a beautiful historical setting. It would give players something in their sandbox besides aiming and shooting to keep them interested. Sailaway has no PvE content at all. Or PvP content for that matter. Sailing around is the content. If only they had your beautiful ships, and the occasional naval battle... I have a whole thread on the topic here.
  4. Juan Navarre

    Fun PVE for everyone?!

    You create a new character for the PvP server. You won't lose anything on PvE.
  5. Juan Navarre

    Why not have sailing in the OW?

    Wierd. And you are zoomed in all the way with your scroll wheel? I wonder if it has to do with which ship you are sailing. I seem to be able to stay on the deck in my Indefatigable. Might be because it goes right to the bow chasers or stern chasers. Anyway, I agree that a first person view from the helm would be ideal.
  6. Juan Navarre

    Why not have sailing in the OW?

    Can't walk around the deck, but if you are zoomed all the way in with the scroll wheel, you can look around a full 360 left and right and stay on the deck in the center of the ship. That is how I usually do most of the battles, just turning from starboard aiming to bow chasers, to larboard, to stern chasers. Unfortunately, if you press Ctrl+H, it won't seem to let you switch out chain, grape, charge, etc... So it is tricky to do the whole battle without the holographic HUD.
  7. Juan Navarre

    Idea: Bring AGONY to NA-OW...!

    I really thought, reading the game's description, that the OW was what the game was all about. That it would be like Sailaway, but with 18th century brigs and frigates instead of modern cruisers and catamarans, and with the occasional naval battle to spice things up. There is no combat in Sailaway. Sailing the OW is the entirety of the game. Just like the OW is the entirety of MS Flight Simulator and XPlane. The OW is fun in those games because there is more to sailing a boat or flying a plane than just WASD around the map. Sailing in the open world would be fun if there were any actual sailing involved.
  8. Juan Navarre

    Add additional basic starting ship "HMS Surprise"

    This seems complex, contrived and like it would require a completely new mechanism. Missions in an assigned ship dedicated to that mission would be simple, intuitive, and the mechanism is already in place for the tutorials. As the OP observed, the appeal of the game for many is to be in an interactive Jack Aubrey story. Jack got assigned to the Sophie, and told what his mission was. He didn't have to purchase her, outfit her with mods and upgrades and then wander around looking for something to do. It is just intuitive that if you have the skills, but don't have the capital, you sail someone else's ship until you can afford one of your own.
  9. Juan Navarre

    Add additional basic starting ship "HMS Surprise"

    As I mentioned in another thread, missions on the PvP server should play matchmaker. French players getting a mission in a 5th rate at no cost will defend their nations weapons shipment against British players whose mission is to capture said French weapons shipment, etc... If you have no control over what ship and upgrades you are using, it would be a way to create balanced encounters in which people's objective will be to accomplish their mission, rather than to preserve their irreplacable Hercules, so that they don't get stuck in a cutter. Letting people run missions without having to use their cutter to capture a snow, and then using their Snow to capture a Cerberus, and then using their Cerberus to capture a Belle Poule, just to get back to where they were each time they lose their ship, won't ruin the game economy. It would in fact be less disastrous than the current setup, where deleting and starting a new character is extremely lucrative. I've seen those naval clocks going for 10Mil, and a Hercules note going for 4Mil + 800 combat marks + an Agamemnon. Even aside from all the nonsense that can be done with alts, if I were inclined to join a clan, what would keep me from outfitting my whole clan with all the Hercules notes and Naval Clocks they want, and then getting a few quid pro quo from my clan afterwards? Seems to me that if you get no starting cash, no ships, and the reward for passing the exam is just the rank, and the missions that go along with that rank, it would eliminate a lot of those types of shenanigans, and be better for the game economy all around.
  10. Juan Navarre

    Add additional basic starting ship "HMS Surprise"

    I am not quite sure how you distinguish between captaining someone else's ship, and being provided with a ship for a specific event and nothing else. Is it your ship that you own and can do whatever you want with, or is it a ship that you are captaining, but do not own?
  11. Juan Navarre

    Add additional basic starting ship "HMS Surprise"

    Not true. M&C can have a max of 280. 400 is post captain. I think a better route than having basic ships to buy for free like the cutter, would be missions where you captain someone else's ship. So, for example, a M&C without a ship of their own could take a mission in a Surprise, which they would be unable to sell. They would only be able to attack the target of the mission, and would not be able to place anything in the hold, or remove the supplies provided from the ship. If they have the fleet perk, they can keep any ship that they capture during the mission, and by completing the mission, they will receive enough reals to afford to buy their own ship.
  12. Juan Navarre

    Boarding + 'Determined Defender' suggestion

    I stand corrected.
  13. Juan Navarre

    Boarding + 'Determined Defender' suggestion

    Historical accounts aside, I can't think of any mechanism that would prevent ships with similar velocities from grappling because of their speed through the water. The leeward ship would presumably be able to cast grappling hooks from further away due to height advantage of the increased heel. Other than that, what else would STW or SOG affect with regard to casting grappling hooks?
  14. Juan Navarre

    Boarding + 'Determined Defender' suggestion

    A better historian than I might correct me on this, but I sincerely doubt there are any accounts of boarding that include the speeds of the ships. 18th century ships were not equipped with the precision speedometers we are accustomed to in Naval Action. They had chip logs, which were pieces of wood cast overboard and attached lines with knots tied at regular intervals. A sailor would count the knots that were payed out over a period of time accounted by use of a sandglass. Needless to say, this involved process would only be accurate at all if the ship were kept on course for the duration, and would be impractical to use in a pitched battle while maneuvering to board an enemy. Additionally, the crew might have had other priorities than determining their speed at the time. We can infer that grappling was accomplished at a variety of speeds though. The first and most obvious inference is that if bringing the enemies speed down was a challenge that boarders had to overcome, there would be some account of it, and of the techniques used to reduce an enemies speed to a point where boarding would be possible. There are also accounts such as the 1779 battle of the HMS Serapis and USS Bonhomme Richard, in which Captain John Paul Jones tethered his ship to Serapis as a counter to the smaller ship's superior maneuverability and gunpower. If he had to reduce the Serapis to 2 knots before lashing the ships together, then lashing the ships together would not be an effective way to reduce her maneuverability, since it would be a moot point if he had to effectively reduce her maneuverability in order to reduce her maneuverability. Further, in 1799, the USS Chesapeake was heeling enough that she could only hit the rigging of the Shannon, when she lost maneuverability and became entangled with the other ship, and was subsequently boarded. The only way she would be heeling that much is if she was under enough sail to be going more than 2 knots.
  15. Juan Navarre

    Idea: Norfolk nAhab and his White Whale...

    Did they remove trading and crafting and switch to an arena style deathmatch game? I must have missed the memo.
×