But in the Le Requin you don't need any mods to be able to accomplish out running the enemy, which makes it even worse in terms of risk/reward: go sail an unmodified ship to hunt noobs, if you get caught out: no worries as you only lost repairs.
It also seems to be the same few people saying there is nothing wrong with the Le Requin... I have the Hercules DLC and I'm happy to say that it too has issues. A good player of any game realises and admits when something is broken.
As for the stats, numbers can hide many things real ingame experience shows. I have given up giving aid to players (besides advice on how to escape) when I hear a call for help about a Le Requin in our reinforcement zone as no ship I have can give aid in sinking one as they just run even from other Requins